Earlier this week, I discussed how I ditched my scale for the betterment of my emotional health and sanity. But that doesn’t mean I don’t have mechanisms for tracking physical progress and health.
I majored in Economics. I love data. I need numbers. So what’s a number nerd to do when you take away a daily metric like weighing? Well, let’s talk about data. At a very high level, we can break it into two categories: qualitative and quantitative.
Qualitative data is what it sounds like – measured by qualities. Qualitative data includes the outcomes of a situation that you cannot measure, but you can observe. Quantitative data is what you can quantify, i.e. put numbers to. There are accessible methods for measuring quantitative data. Both types of data are important and helpful when discussing tracking of progress when it comes to health.
First, let’s look at the qualitative data that can be used (and that I use) to track how I’m doing health-wise. I like to think of qualitative data when it comes to health as “quality of life” data. How is my quality of life? The things I tend to look to to measure my quality of life are:
- Do I wake up feeling refreshed and energized?
- Is my energy steady throughout the day, or does it dip in the afternoon?
- Is my digestion comfortable, i.e. no nausea, bloating, or the ever-classy gas?
- Am I going #2. (I really wish there was a way to talk about health without going to the poo topic, but thus far I just don’t see a way).
- Do I fall asleep easily?
- Do I wake up in the middle of the night craving sugar?
- Am I cranky or generally happy?
If one of those things above is off or not what I want it to be, I can generally trace it back to something. Did I eat something I typically don’t? Did I stay up too late mindlessly reading about people’s dogs, babies and other nonsense of Facebook? Have I eaten enough fat that day? Have I eaten enough period that day?
This “quality of life” data is im-port-ant. It requires for you to listen to your body and take note of when you feel something not quite right, or downright wrong. If there is one single goal of pursuing a healthy lifestyle, isn’t it to improve our quality of life; to live longer, happier, more fulfilled lives? I think there is tremendous value in listening to your body, and perhaps picking a handful of things (like my list above) that you can use to keep tabs on your body and how you’re doing. This article provides an exhaustive list compiled by Whole9 of qualitative data points – check it out! 174,203 Ways to Measure Health (Besides the Scale)
But what about the numbers? How could you use some relevant metrics to measure progress that won’t turn you into a neurotic mess?
First, let me point out that weighing yourself frequently may not make you a neurotic mess like me. If that’s the case for you, righteous man. But that still doesn’t mean that scale weight is reliable. I recognize that for some people, scale weight might be the only viable option right now for measuring progress. If that’s the case, I say weigh on with your bad self.
- Put some quantitative measures to the qualitative data. Create a way to track your energy throughout the day, by ranking it on a scale from 1-5 at set points throughout the day. Or maybe rate your previous night’s sleep upon waking. Note anytime you feel digestive discomfort, then look back at your week and analyze how often is it happening. Try eliminating what you think is the culprit, and track again.
- Track your food intake and a quality of life metric. Another way to do this is to track what you eat throughout the day, then relate it to things like energy level and digestion. I am not hugely wild about tracking everything I eat all the time, since it tends to make me feel a little crazy. But I will do this from time to time to get an accurate picture of what I’m taking in, and I know some people really like this type of tracking.
- Body fat percentage. I delved into why scale weight is often misleading (including how I lost 7% body fat and not a single pound last year) earlier this week. I am much more a fan of using body fat percentage to track if weight loss is your goal. Because for most people, when you say you want to lose weight, you really want to lose fat. Most people don’t say “I want to lose a bunch of muscle and have no definition”. No, you want to lose the layer of fat that covers up your lean muscle. Measuring body fat gives a much more accurate picture of what you’re actually looking to lose. This article covers the 5 most common ways of measuring body fat. I highly recommend getting a pro method involved to ensure accuracy!
The above three are good, but they’re still not my favorite. I personally have come to love and rely on Poliquin BioSignature Modulation. I am not affiliated in any way to Poliquin or the BioSignature deal in any way. I just have found it so helpful that I want to endorse it to others. I first heard about BioSignature from this Robb Wolf podcast, and I looked up a practitioner in my area and scheduled an appointment. At the time I was eating a pretty clean paleo diet, but could not lean out for the life of me. I figured BioSignature was worth a try.
BioSignature assessments are administered by trained practitioners. The basic process is they measure your body fat at twelve different sites. Each site gives insight into a different element of your hormonal profile. You get an overall body fat percentage read, but you also get a very pointed depiction of what is actually happening in your body. You are generally not equally big everywhere, and it is a shame to ignore where your body is storing fat.
When I did my first BioSignature assessment, I learned that I was carrying fat in my love handles, stomach, and calves, which shows that my body was not managing blood sugar well, had jacked up cortisol, and my sleep sucked. Instead of haphazardly trying various things to improve my body composition, I was then able to prioritize my actions to address these most problematic hormonal imbalances. By regularly tracking those 12 sites, myself and my trainer were able to adapt my routine, my food, exercise, and supplementation to best address my personal issues. I don’t think BioSignature is a perfect science (because pretty much nothing is) but it was very helpful and enlightening for me.
Now that my focus is on health and not fat loss, I am still regularly having BioSignature assessments to address other hormonal issues. It turns out that my estrogen was pretty high, hence the estrogen detox protocol I’ve been doing this month. I am looking to ramp up my exercise next month, and will use BioSignature to monitor cortisol and mitigate over-training. Blood sugar management continues to be a difficulty for me, and I will continue to monitor that critical element of health through BioSignature.
If you can, I recommend you look up a practitioner in your area. If you’re in the Northern Colorado area, I cannot recommend my trainer enough. Check him out here.
Haven’t heard of the bio signature test until reading this. Now I’m interested. Have you ever had blood tests done to compare hormone levels to your biosig results?
Also it seems like with the diet part they essentially recommend lower carb overall right?
How fast do you see results after you find a target to focus on?
Thanks!
Yes, I actually got blood work shortly after my initial assessment that confirmed many of the findings from BioSignature. For example, BioSig showed my cortisol was way up, and the blood work was exactly the same. As I mentioned, I don’t think it’s perfect, because nothing is. But I do believe in the scientific underpinnings of BioSignature, and that it is valid.
Poliquin does advocate low-carb for a lot of scenarios, but it’s not the only option. Ideally, your practitioner should be able to make recommendations based on your activity level and carb tolerance. Do you do BJJ? That would likely require more carbs… have you read Robb Wolf’s recent series on low-carb? If you haven’t it’s a good read. He does BJJ too.
Finally – I saw results within four weeks, but I’m guessing it would vary for each person. Depending on what is out of whack for you, the protocol might be totally different and take shorter or longer to start resolving. My initial changes based on my biosig were lifestyle and diet changes, but they do also recommend supplementation as well. Poliquin has a supplement line, so I was pretty wary of ordering their (expensive) supplements for a while. But everything that I’ve invested in has really served me well. I had to learn first hand that you get what you pay for in terms of supplements. Overall, I think it’s worth checking out if you can!
Awesome!
Ya I’ve seen Robb Wolf’s 3 part series… and it really got me thinking. I’m still in the midst of my own (Day 52 of 60 days) Nutritional Ketosis experiment so I don’t wanna mess things up with upping carbs, but he really gave me a lot to think about.
After reading your post I think BioSig is something I’m definitely going to experiment with in the future.
Which supplements do you get? Did you start using the Poliquin recommended supplements? I’ve actually been eyeing the marks daily apple stuff recently.
I would love to hear more about your nutritional ketosis experiment! Sounds really interesting. And you’re so close to the end, way to go. I have gotten many of the supplements recommended, but first and foremost I have adhered to the lifestyle recommendations of my practitioner, which have had a huge impact. My favorite supplements from Poliquin are probably Fenuplex for blood sugar management and UberMag (magnesium) for sleeping. I had done other magnesium supplements, but I’ve found that one really works best out of all I’ve tried. Right now I’m using a few detoxing supplements to estrogen detox. That process isn’t far enough along for me to really have an opinion yet. I haven’t tried any of the Primal Blueprint supplements, but I would be interested to!
I write about my experiment at bjjcaveman.com
Hi Susie,
Thanks a lot for your post. I have been aware of the Biosignature service for a while and they even have it in my home town of Perth here in Australia but the main thing that has put me off has been the likelihood of getting the hard sell at the end of it to spend hundreds of dollars in their supplement line. How essential are the supplements normally to restoring the hormonal imbalances identified in the Biosig?
I don’t really have a lot of cash to be spending on supplements on the moment with two little kids and a wife on maternity leave!
Hey there. I can’t speak for the practitioner in your area, but I have never felt uncomfortable pressure from my BioSig practitioner. I was wary of the same thing! My guy makes many lifestyle recommendations that have helped me a ton, and that was well worth it. Some issues really have required the use of supplements, but I have the freedom to say “no” to anything I don’t want to do or can’t afford. If something is just out of budget, I will say so and we’ll prioritize what I will get based on what issue is most serious. I think you have every right to go in there and set the expectation from the beginning what you can and can’t do, and see if the practitioner is game. I also think the assessment is very valuable for guiding lifestyle choices like nutrition and exercise, and then maybe adding in the supplements that you can afford when you can. Congrats on the new little one!
Thanks, he is a little champ and gives us so much joy, especially now that he is starting to smile and laugh a little. His big brother is taking more convincing than we thought that it was a good idea to introduce another baby into the scenario but he is only two and gradually coming around.
That is good feedback on the Biosig practicioner. I am looking into that and the Chek Metabolic Typing method at the moment as well but just trying to collect as much background info before I jump in. I am leaning towards the Chek stuff a bit more at the moment because it seems to be a little less reliant on supps. The structural balance assessment that the Poliquin trainers do as well does appeal to me though.
Good luck with your detoxing this month!
My sister was 3 when I was born. When I was two weeks old, she told my mom “I think it’s time to take Susie back to the hospital now.” Haha! She eventually adjusted and now we’re best friends.
Cool! If you do the CHEK method, I would LOVE to hear more about it and your experiences. I’m always open to new methods of measuring and tracking, I like to be a nerd about that stuff. Take care!
Ha, that is too funny. Lucas said exactly the same thing! Take baby Oliver back to hostable…(he had only just turned two years old).
Hopefully they will end up best friends too.